Shave · Best of
What is the best pomade for thick hair?
For thick hair, look for three words on the label: strong or extreme hold, matte finish, and water-based so it washes out. Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz has all three and the best rating of the pomades that do (4.6 stars from 7,170 ratings). Smooth Viking Water-Based Hair Clay 2 oz fits the same description and has the most ratings. If you want shine and a lighter hold, Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 oz is the cheapest well-rated one at $3.75 an ounce.
Our picks
Thick hair: strongest hold, matte
Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz
Hold: Extreme. Matte. Water-based. 4.6 stars from 7,170 ratings.1, 2
Thick hair: most reviewed
Smooth Viking Water-Based Hair Clay 2 oz
Hold: Strong. Matte. Water-based. 4.2 stars from 13,792 ratings.3
Lighter hold, with shine
Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 oz
Hold: Medium; shine: medium. The cheapest per ounce with 10,000+ ratings. 4.7 stars from 28,537 ratings.4
- Strongest hold: the highest star rating among pomades whose maker or title says extreme, high, strong or heavy hold, with a matte finish, that wash out with water; 5,000+ ratings.
- Most reviewed: the pomade with the most ratings that fits the same description.
- Lighter hold: the lowest price per ounce among pomades with 10,000+ ratings.
A tie in stars goes to the product with more ratings. Hold and shine are the maker's own words, not a common scale. Only listings sold by Amazon or the brand are shown. Prices on Amazon, November 1, 2026.5
What the makers say
Hold, finish and washing out
There is no standard hold scale, so we quote each maker and keep the three words together.
Layrite says extreme hold, matte, water-based
Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz: hold extreme, shine matte, water-based yes. Water-based pomade washes out with water, which is why we require it for thick hair.1
All the pomades we checked
Cheapest per ounce first.
Hold, finish and washes-out are the maker's own wording from its page or the Amazon title. Per ounce = price divided by the ounces in the listing.
Pomades and clays (8)
| Product | Hold (maker's word) | Finish | Washes out with water | Per ounce | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 ozHold (maker's word): Medium · Finish: Medium · Washes out with water: Yes | $3.75 an oz | $14.99 | |||
 Suavecito Matte Pomade 4 ozHold (maker's word): Medium · Finish: Matte · Washes out with water: Yes | $3.75 an oz | $14.99 | |||
 Layrite Original Pomade 4.2 ozHold (maker's word): Medium · Finish: Natural / medium · Washes out with water: Yes | $5.71 an oz | $24.00 | |||
 Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 ozHold (maker's word): Extreme · Finish: Matte · Washes out with water: Yes | $6.35 an oz | $27.00 | |||
 Smooth Viking Water-Based Hair Clay 2 ozHold (maker's word): Strong · Finish: Matte · Washes out with water: Yes | $7.50 an oz | $14.99 | |||
 Baxter of California Clay Pomade 2 ozHold (maker's word): Strong · Finish: Matte · Washes out with water: No (oil-based) | $10.20 an oz | $20.40 | |||
 Brickell Styling Clay Pomade 2 ozHold (maker's word): High · Finish: Matte · Washes out with water: No (oil-based) | $11.50 an oz | $23.00 | |||
 Hanz de Fuko Claymation 2 ozHold (maker's word): High · Finish: Matte / semi-matte · Washes out with water: Yes | $14.00 an oz | $28.00 |
Related questions
Shave · ComparedHonest Amish or Viking Revolution: which beard balm and oil should you buy?
Buy the Viking Revolution balm for the lower price per ounce; for oil, Honest Amish costs less per ounce. One choosing line per product.
Shave · Best ofWhat is the best safety razor for a beginner?
Our picks for a first safety razor, from mild to adjustable, with a three-step first shave from the maker and which blades to start with.
Shave · ComparedHarry's or Gillette: which razor refills should you buy?
Buy Harry's: $2.08 a cartridge against $3.31 for Gillette Fusion5, both with 5 blades. Refills and kits compared.
Body · Is it worth it?Is Dr. Squatch soap worth it?
Dr. Squatch soap is $1.19 an ounce, more than Duke Cannon and a little less than Every Man Jack. Labels, prices and ratings compared.
Questions people ask
What is the best pomade for thick hair?
By star rating among strong-hold, matte, water-based pomades with 5,000 or more ratings, Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz: 4.6 stars from 7,170 ratings.2
How do I use it?
Layrite says: “Rub a small amount thoroughly between palms until the product softens/warms... Distribute evenly through damp or dry hair and style/shape as desired.”1 Suavecito adds: “Applying pomade to dry hair creates a stronger hold.”4
What should I look for on the label?
Three things: a strong, high or extreme hold, a matte finish, and water-based or water-soluble wording so it washes out.
Which pomade is cheapest?
Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 oz, at $3.75 an ounce among pomades with 10,000 or more ratings. Its hold is medium.
Is there a strong-hold pomade that is not water-based?
Reuzel Pink is an oil-based pomade with strong hold and medium shine per its maker, but it was sold by a reseller on Amazon when we looked, so we do not list it.
What is the difference between a clay and a pomade?
We go by each maker's wording: the clays here are described as matte, and the classic pomades as having some shine.
Sources
- Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz: ingredient list on its Amazon listing, read November 1, 2026.
- Star ratings and rating counts: the Amazon page of each product, read November 1, 2026.
- Smooth Viking Water-Based Hair Clay 2 oz: ingredient list on its Amazon listing, read November 1, 2026.
- Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 oz: details on its Amazon listing, read November 1, 2026.
- Prices and photos: Amazon product data, read November 1, 2026. Price per ounce = listing price divided by the total ounces in the listing.
Listing read for each product shown (listing details, November 1, 2026): Baxter of California Clay Pomade 2 oz · Brickell Styling Clay Pomade 2 oz · Hanz de Fuko Claymation 2 oz · Layrite Cement Hair Clay 4.25 oz · Layrite Original Pomade 4.2 oz · Smooth Viking Water-Based Hair Clay 2 oz · Suavecito Original Hold Pomade 4 oz · Suavecito Matte Pomade 4 oz.
Only products sold by Amazon.com or the brand itself are listed, because other sellers can charge much more. A product with no offer today is left out. See how we check.